Unbelievable? Do we have a soul - or are we just bodies and brains? Dr Claire Gilbert vs Harry Amos
Sep 11, 2025
Dr. Claire Gilbert, a writer and ethicist with deep ties to spirituality and ecology, shares her transformative journey through faith and personal trials. In contrast, Harry Amos, a philosopher and former Christian, debates the soul's existence using science and consciousness studies. They explore everything from neuroscience and dualism to the spiritual essence of dogs and the ineffable nature of spiritual experiences. This engaging dialogue challenges listeners to reflect on the meaning of life, consciousness, and human connection.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Cancer Taught Compassionate Presence
- Claire found Julian of Norwich's writings personally consoling during grueling myeloma treatment.
- She learned to face and love the cancer, turning suffering into a source of meaning and joy.
Bringing Spiritual Depth To Public Service
- Claire describes founding ethics institutes and mentoring public servants through soul work at St Paul's and Westminster Abbey.
- She used Julian of Norwich's writings to foster spiritual depth in busy public leaders.
Ecology Requires A Non-Dualist Mindset
- Claire criticizes Enlightenment dualism for enabling domination of nature and causing ecological harm.
- She urges a porous, responsive relationship to the world rather than objectifying control.
