Episode 472 - Moments of Truth

Jan 28, 2026

A deadly shooting is used as a turning point to examine truth, justice and cultural values. The conversation riffs on Plato and the clash between soul-corrupting lies and myths that reveal meaning. Political falsehoods and post-truth cynicism are unpacked as obstacles to living honestly. Poems and calls to civic responsibility offer ways for people to resist and live in truth.

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Books

Transcript

Episode notes

ANECDOTE

Minneapolis Shooting As A Moment Of Truth

Michael Meade recounts the Minneapolis shooting of ICU nurse Alex Preddy, emphasizing the incident was filmed from multiple angles.
He stresses Preddy was disarmed and fatally shot ten times, urging people not to deny what they can see.

INSIGHT

Collective Tragedy Requires Cultural Change

Meade frames the moment as part of a larger collective tragedy that demands cultural transformation, not just political change.
He links the struggle for truth and meaning to a need to reshape the quality of human life now.

INSIGHT

Plato's 'Lies Of The Soul' Explained

Meade draws on Plato's Republic to distinguish harmful 'lies of the soul' from life-enhancing 'noble lies.'
He warns that lies internalized in the soul prevent people from seeking healing or truth.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

This episode begins with the recent shooting in Minneapolis in which an intensive care nurse named Alex Pretti was shot ten times by ICE and border patrol agents. There are fateful occasions when a tragic event becomes a moment of truth for both individual life and the collective meaning and core values of a culture. Michael Meade suggests that: "We are now, and may be for some time, in a collective tragedy that involves a battle for truth and meaning, but also the need for a transformation of culture that is aimed not only at the need for political change, but also at a transformation of the quality of human life at this time."

Meade turns back to Plato's Republic, one of the foundational works of Western philosophy, that explores the meaning of justice and the struggle between "lies of the soul" and the need to "live in truth." Because the current administration is captive to its own lies, it must falsify everything. It must falsify the past by trying to rewrite history. It must falsify the present by telling people not to believe their own eyes and it must seek to falsify the future by blatantly denying the truth and avoiding accountability.

In the end, it comes down to the people, as "living the lie" must be confronted with living in truth. The point becomes not only the exposure of all the false poses and hollow pretenses that living in lies requires; but also the ancient and immediate revelation that it is not only possible, but truly essential that people who seek freedom and human dignity find ways to live within truth when faced with an administration of lies.

Thank you for listening to and supporting Living Myth. You can further support this podcast by becoming a member of Living Myth Premium. Members receive bonus episodes each month, access to the full archives of over 740 episodes and a 30% discount on all events, courses and book and audio titles.

Learn more and join this community of listeners at patreon.com/livingmyth

Along with these free weekly podcasts, you can now read free weekly essays and long form posts by Michael Meade on Substack.

Learn more and subscribe at: michaeljmeade.substack.com

If you enjoy this podcast, we appreciate you leaving a review wherever you listen and sharing it with your friends. On behalf of Michael Meade and the whole Mosaic staff, we wish you well and thank you for your support of our work.