Shedunnit

The Perfect Plan

Mar 4, 2026
A tense tale of a long con, a staged murder, and an elaborate alibi built through impersonation and broadcasts. The plot tracks a cunning secretary's careful planning, a wrongful conviction, and the slow unravelling of confidence into paranoia. It ends with a dramatic on-air confession and the public scrambling to interpret what really happened.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Why This Story Appeals To Detective Fans

  • Caroline Crampton frames the story as a near-ideal match for classic detective tropes: secretaries, media details, inverted plot and moral commentary.
  • She highlights James Hilton's unusual one-off crime piece amid a career known for Lost Horizon and Goodbye, Mr Chips.
ANECDOTE

Scarsdale's Meticulous Murder Plan

  • James Hilton's short story The Perfect Plan centres on Scarsdale, a secretary who meticulously plans to murder his employer and fabricate an airtight alibi via a radio broadcast.
  • Scarsdale fakes Sir George's BBC broadcast, steals bearer bonds, and buries them while letting a tramp (Hansel) be arrested for the murder.
INSIGHT

Broadcast As An Ironclad Alibi

  • The story uses the radio broadcast as both alibi and dramatic device to show how media can be weaponised in alibi construction.
  • Scarsdale's perfect-voice impersonation in the BBC studio creates a public alibi verifiable by thousands of listeners and station staff.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app