The Herd with Colin Cowherd 3 & Out - Massive Mailbag
Mar 25, 2026
A massive mailbag tackles Kyler Murray’s fit with the Vikings and realistic expectations for his mobility and wins. A heated take on tampering and NIL-era enforcement problems. A playful debate on whether Tom Brady could still play at 48. Trade and value talks on AJ Brown, Nick Bosa trade risk, and which NFC East teams are worth investing in. Reflections on scouting misses and ranking short quarterbacks.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Why Kyler Murray’s Ceiling Feels Limited
- John Middlecoff doubts Kyler Murray can sustain elite production in a run-heavy, scramble style due to injuries and decreased pocket passing.
- He contrasts Kyler with pocket-capable stars like Lamar, citing lost rushing impact and recent seasons with lower TD totals and durability concerns.
Dabo's Tampering Rant Won't Change The Market
- Middlecoff says college tampering and NIL chaos mean coaches complain but rarely stop because the rules are weak and enforcement is inconsistent.
- He frames Dabo's rant as understandable but mostly symbolic since programs will exploit NIL advantages until rules change.
Tom Brady Could Still Dominate A Game But Not A Season
- Tom Brady, at 48, retains elite accuracy and decision-making but lacks mobility and arm strength compared with modern top quarterbacks.
- Middlecoff argues Brady could excel in single games but likely couldn't endure a full NFL season given today's pass-rush depth.