The Fr. Mike Schmitz Catholic Podcast Why Did Judas Betray Jesus?
33 snips
Jan 29, 2026 A probing look at why Judas betrayed Jesus and whether he thought he was helping fulfill a plan. Discussion of Scripture’s account that money motivated the betrayal and how divine knowledge and human free will interact. Contrast between despair and repentance, showing the tragedy of a friendship turned traitorous. A closing reminder that restoration is possible for those who turn back.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Assume The Best When Motives Are Unclear
- When motives are unclear, choose to assume the best by filling the gap with trust.
- Fr. Mike Schmitz recommends graciously interpreting others' actions unless they've proven untrustworthy.
Gospel Record On Judas's Motive
- The Gospels explicitly state Judas betrayed Jesus for money, and three accounts record this motive.
- Fr. Mike Schmitz insists we must accept the historical record rather than reframe Judas's motive romantically.
Allowing Versus Ordering Betrayal
- Jesus saying "what you're going to do, do quickly" accepts betrayal but does not command it.
- God never wills sin or condemns anyone, so Jesus allowing betrayal differs from ordering it.