The Herd with Colin Cowherd THE HERD - Hour 1 - The Most Underrated Team in the NFC, Optimism for Caleb Williams
Sep 11, 2025
Dianna Russini, Senior NFL Insider for The Athletic, brings her expertise to the discussion, diving into the potential of underrated NFL teams and the exciting prospects of Caleb Williams. They analyze the injury woes plaguing the 49ers and the implications of starting Mac Jones at QB. The conversation touches on the historical strengths of the Green Bay Packers and their draft strategies, as well as the dynamics within the NFC North. Tune in for insights on team strategies and upcoming matchups!
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Injuries Expose Drafting Gaps
- Colin predicted San Francisco could finish third due to organizational brittleness and missed draft picks.
- He points to recent injuries (Brock Purdy out) as validation of that concern.
Caleb Williams' Operational Concerns
- Colin is cautious about Caleb Williams after a rough second half and operational mistakes in Week 1.
- He highlights overthrows, pre-snap/penalty issues, and rookie operational struggles as red flags.
Early Stats Mirror Troubling Past Cases
- Williams leads the league by a wide margin in overthrows and struggles with short-area accuracy and operations.
- Colin compares his first 18 starts statistically to Mitch Trubisky, raising durability and accuracy questions.