The Herd with Colin Cowherd Colin Cowherd Podcast - College Football Playoff Reaction: Indiana Rolls The Tide, Oregon Throttles Texas Tech, Miami Upsets Ohio State
Jan 2, 2026
John Middlekauff, a former NFL scout and host of '3 and Out,' joins Colin to dissect the thrilling college football playoff scene. They celebrate Indiana's shocking triumph over Alabama, diving into Curt Cignetti's elite coaching methods. The duo thoroughly analyzes quarterback Fernando Mendoza's standout qualities. Oregon's dominance over Texas Tech is another highlight, showcasing their youthful talent. They also explore Miami's impressive upset against Ohio State, crediting Mario Cristobal's recruiting brilliance. Finally, they critique Lincoln Riley's struggles to build a solid defense at USC.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Cignetti's Slow-Building Credibility
- Colin recounts Kurt Cignetti's long climb and 'Google me' moment to show his underestimated résumé.
- He likens Cignetti's background to a methodical, experienced operator who built Indiana's success.
Fernando Mendoza: Prototype NFL QB
- John Middlekauff and Colin highlight Mendoza's strengths vs. the blitz and underneath throws.
- They compare Mendoza to Andrew Luck for size, decision-making, and consistent short passing.
Physicality Trumps Flair In Playoff Teams
- Colin and John note Miami and Indiana as the country's most physically capable teams this season.
- They stress tackling and running ability as key indicators of a team's playoff readiness.