
The Commentary Magazine Podcast Here's Some Stuff We Don't Like
11 snips
Aug 21, 2025 The hosts dive into their literary pet peeves, expressing disdain for renowned classics like Dickens and Melville. They discuss the challenges of connecting with towering figures in literature while offering humorous critiques. A surprising section highlights the complexities of historical narratives, contrasting interpretations of popular works like 'Hamilton.' They also debate the merits of adaptations versus original texts, especially with Tolkien. The conversation takes an intriguing turn towards the impacts of modern reinterpretations on our appreciation of classics.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Moby-Dick As A White Whale
- Christine Rosen says Moby-Dick is her white whale and she repeatedly fails to finish it despite liking Melville's short stories.
- She read a scholarly book to motivate herself but still stopped after about 50 pages.
Why Moby-Dick Divides Readers
- The panel notes Moby-Dick originally flopped and caused Melville decades of silence.
- John Podhoretz highlights Melville's exhaustive digressions like the 35-page Cetology chapter that polarize readers.
Not Sold On Hamilton's Score
- Abe Greenwald says Hamilton is wildly overrated to him because the music leaves him cold even though he admires its story and inclusiveness.
- He watched but rarely replays the songs and doesn't engage with the cast recording.


















