Controversies in Church History

What We've Been Reading 2025 (ish)

Feb 15, 2026
A lively reading roundup covering novels from Waugh, Ishiguro, Fosse, Cather, and McCarthy. Discussions range from memory and forgetting to hypnotic encounters and luminous landscape prose. Short critiques examine Romanticism, Romanitas, and journalistic cultural claims. Teasers about forthcoming deep dives into schisms, Nouvelle Théologie, and patron plans close the show.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
ANECDOTE

Nearly Abandoned Fosse, Then Hooked

  • Taylor recounts reading Jon Fosse's A Shining and nearly abandoning it due to its repetitive first-person voice.
  • He stayed and found the hypnotic style pulled him into the protagonist's dissolving consciousness.
INSIGHT

Guadalupe As Bridge To Nahua Fulfillment

  • Taylor says Guadalupe and the Flower World Prophecy reframes Our Lady of Guadalupe through Nahua traditions, arguing cultural continuity aided conversion.
  • He finds the Gonzalezes' thesis persuasive that Guadalupe fulfilled indigenous prophetic expectations without syncretism.
INSIGHT

Chiron's Book Is the Traditionalism Standard

  • Taylor calls Yves Chiron's Between Rome and Rebellion the definitive history of French Catholic traditionalism.
  • He emphasizes France as the movement's "beating heart" and Chiron's work as essential for serious study.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app