
Controversies in Church History What We've Been Reading 2025 (ish)
Feb 15, 2026
A lively reading roundup covering novels from Waugh, Ishiguro, Fosse, Cather, and McCarthy. Discussions range from memory and forgetting to hypnotic encounters and luminous landscape prose. Short critiques examine Romanticism, Romanitas, and journalistic cultural claims. Teasers about forthcoming deep dives into schisms, Nouvelle Théologie, and patron plans close the show.
47:50
Nearly Abandoned Fosse, Then Hooked
- Taylor recounts reading Jon Fosse's A Shining and nearly abandoning it due to its repetitive first-person voice.
- He stayed and found the hypnotic style pulled him into the protagonist's dissolving consciousness.
Guadalupe As Bridge To Nahua Fulfillment
- Taylor says Guadalupe and the Flower World Prophecy reframes Our Lady of Guadalupe through Nahua traditions, arguing cultural continuity aided conversion.
- He finds the Gonzalezes' thesis persuasive that Guadalupe fulfilled indigenous prophetic expectations without syncretism.
Chiron's Book Is the Traditionalism Standard
- Taylor calls Yves Chiron's Between Rome and Rebellion the definitive history of French Catholic traditionalism.
- He emphasizes France as the movement's "beating heart" and Chiron's work as essential for serious study.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app 1 chevron_right 2 chevron_right 3 chevron_right 4 chevron_right 5 chevron_right 6 chevron_right 7 chevron_right 8 chevron_right 9 chevron_right 10 chevron_right 11 chevron_right 12 chevron_right 13 chevron_right 14 chevron_right
Intro
00:00 • 2min
Waugh's Sword of Honour: Guy Crouchback's Arc
02:09 • 3min
Ishiguro's The Buried Giant: Memory and Forgetting
05:06 • 5min
Jon Fosse's A Shining: Hypnotic, Ambiguous Encounter
10:08 • 3min
Guadalupe and the Flower World Prophecy
13:12 • 3min
Between Rome and Rebellion: Chiron on Traditionalism
16:30 • 6min
Willa Cather's Death Comes for the Archbishop
23:00 • 3min
Critique: The Triumph of Romanticism
25:54 • 6min
Critique: The Iron Scepter and Romanitas
31:54 • 3min
Thomistic Mystagogy: Aquinas on the Mass
34:29 • 2min
Cormac McCarthy's No Country for Old Men
36:53 • 3min
The Unprotected Class: McCarthy on Anti-White Bias
40:08 • 4min
Upcoming Episodes and Patreon Plans
44:21 • 2min
Outro
46:21 • 1min
#
Between Rome and Rebellion

John Pepino

Yves Chiron
#
Thomistic Mystagogy

Urban Hannon
#
Officers and gentlemen


Evelyn Waugh
'Officers and Gentlemen' is the second novel in Evelyn Waugh's 'Sword of Honour' trilogy, following Guy Crouchback's wartime experiences.
The story delves into the chaotic realities of military life, exposing the incompetence and absurdity within the British Army.
Guy's romantic ideals of war clash with the bureaucratic and often farcical nature of his service.
Set against the backdrop of World War II, the novel satirizes the British upper class and their struggles to adapt to modern warfare.
Waugh's sharp wit and keen observations create a poignant and humorous portrayal of a changing world.
The book explores themes of disillusionment, duty, and the loss of traditional values.
#
The Triumph of Romanticism

Gerard Steckler

#204
• Mentioned in 112 episodes
The Road


Tom Stechschulte


Cormac McCarthy
The Road is set in a world that has been devastated by an unspecified cataclysmic event, resulting in the extinction of nearly all life on Earth.
The story follows an unnamed father and his young son as they travel south along the road, carrying their meager possessions and a pistol with only two bullets.
The father, suffering from a worsening respiratory condition, is determined to protect his son from the dangers of their new world, including cannibalistic marauders.
Along their journey, they encounter various survivors, some of whom are cruel and others who show kindness.
The novel explores themes of love, survival, and the preservation of humanity in a world devoid of hope.
Ultimately, the father's health fails, and he dies, but not before ensuring his son's safety with a new family who may offer a chance for a better future.
#79598
The Iron Scepter of the Son of Man

Alan Fimister

#446
• Mentioned in 66 episodes
Blood Meridian
Or, The Evening Redness in the West


Cormac McCarthy
Blood Meridian is a historical novel that depicts the brutal reality of the American West in the mid-19th century.
The story follows a 14-year-old runaway from Tennessee, known as 'the kid', who joins the Glanton gang, a historical group of scalp hunters.
The gang, led by John Joel Glanton and the enigmatic Judge Holden, is contracted to kill and scalp Native Americans but soon devolves into indiscriminate violence against various groups.
The novel explores themes of brutality, the loss of innocence, and the harsh realities of human nature, with Judge Holden serving as a central figure embodying philosophical and sadistic elements.
The book is known for its unflinching portrayal of violence and its allegorical exploration of human existence.

#9057
• Mentioned in 6 episodes
The Buried Giant


Kazuo Ishiguro


David Horovitch
The Buried Giant is set in a mythical post-Arthurian England, where a strange mist causes widespread forgetfulness.
The story follows Axl and Beatrice, an elderly couple, as they embark on a journey to visit their son who lives in a distant village.
Along the way, they encounter various characters, including Saxon warriors, monks, and figures from Arthurian legend.
The novel delves into themes of memory, love, and the consequences of forgetting the past, highlighting the complexities of human nature and the dangers of ignorance.
It blends elements of fantasy, historical fiction, and philosophical reflection to create a narrative that is both a tender love story and a profound exploration of collective memory and its impact on society.

#2995
• Mentioned in 15 episodes
The Unprotected Class

Jeremy Carl

#10908
• Mentioned in 5 episodes
Death Comes for the Archbishop


Willa Cather
Death Comes for the Archbishop is a novel by Willa Cather, published in 1927.
It is based on the lives of Jean-Baptiste Lamy and Joseph Projectus Machebeuf, who worked to establish a Catholic diocese in New Mexico.
The story follows the journey of Bishop Jean Marie Latour and Father Joseph Vaillant as they navigate the challenges of their mission, interact with diverse cultures, and reflect on the complexities of faith and colonialism.
#37576
Guadalupe and the Flower World Prophecy

Monique Gonzalez

Joseph Julian González

#99572
A Forest of Symbols

Abbe Claude Barthes
Abbe Claude Barthes' "A Forest of Symbols" offers a captivating collection of mystagogical interpretations of the liturgy.
The book brings together a wealth of insightful reflections from various periods and authors, creating a tapestry of spiritual understanding.
Barthes' work is not primarily a theological or historical study but rather a florilegium, showcasing the beauty and depth of the liturgical tradition.
It explores the symbolic richness of the liturgy, revealing the profound spiritual meanings embedded within its rites and actions.
"A Forest of Symbols" serves as a valuable resource for anyone seeking a deeper appreciation for the spiritual significance of the liturgy.
#89401
Unconditional Surrender

Gary North

#707
• Mentioned in 47 episodes
No Country for Old Men


Cormac McCarthy
The novel follows the interweaving paths of three central characters: Llewelyn Moss, who stumbles upon a large sum of money at a drug deal gone wrong; Anton Chigurh, a ruthless and principled hitman hired to retrieve the money; and Sheriff Ed Tom Bell, who reflects on the changing world and the moral decay he witnesses.
The story is a harrowing exploration of greed, violence, and the consequences of one's actions, set in the harsh landscape of West Texas in 1980.
It delves into themes of fate vs. free will, good vs.
evil, and the ties of love, blood, and duty that shape destinies.

#7889
• Mentioned in 6 episodes
Shining


Stephen King
In Stephen King's 'The Shining,' Jack Torrance takes a job as the winter caretaker of the Overlook Hotel, hoping to rekindle his writing career and reconnect with his family.
However, the hotel has a dark history and malevolent forces that begin to prey on Jack's sanity.
As the isolation and supernatural influences intensify, Jack descends into madness, terrorizing his wife and son.
The novel explores themes of isolation, addiction, and the destructive power of the past.
King masterfully builds tension and dread, creating a chilling and unforgettable tale of psychological horror.

#1887
• Mentioned in 23 episodes
Klara and the Sun


Kazuo Ishiguro
Set in a dystopian future, 'Klara and the Sun' follows the story of Klara, an Artificial Friend (AF) who is purchased by a mother for her ailing daughter, Josie.
Klara, powered by solar energy, develops a deep bond with Josie and becomes obsessed with the Sun, which she believes has the power to save Josie's life.
The novel delves into themes of loneliness, the nature of consciousness, and the societal implications of genetic engineering and artificial intelligence.
Through Klara's observations and interactions, the book explores the human condition and the complexities of love, faith, and sacrifice in a world marked by social inequality and technological advancements.
The latest episode is a walk-through of what yours truly has been the past year (or so), and gives an update on upcoming episodes and their content (hint: there will be new episodes and they will be awesome). Cheers!
