The Herd with Colin Cowherd Best of The Herd
Dec 19, 2025
In this discussion, Robert Mays, a staff writer for The Athletic specializing in NFL insights, shares his expertise on quarterback evaluation. They delve into Sam Darnold's impressive comeback and mental resilience, contrasting him with the Rams' fourth-quarter struggles. Robert highlights Caleb Williams' evolution as a premier quarterback, focusing on his improved timing and decision-making. The pair also debate the AFC playoff landscape, Josh Allen's unpredictability, and the coaching prowess shaping the 49ers.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Take Giants As Home Underdog
- Take the Giants as an upset vs. the Vikings because New York is running effectively and rookie Jackson Dart is playing well.
- Colin trusts the Giants' recent rushing consistency and Dart's 95 passer rating over the Vikings' thin wins.
Back Bengals Over Dolphins
- Bet Cincinnati (-4.5) over Miami because Joe Burrow historically excels in late-season Week 16/18 games.
- Colin points to Burrow's recent record and Miami starting Quinn Ewers as reasons to back the Bengals.
Take Patriots To Cover Vs Ravens
- Take the Patriots +3 (field goal) vs. Ravens because New England travels well and the Ravens' passing game has struggled at home.
- Colin cites Drake Maye's efficiency and the Patriots' road consistency as the edge.