
Best of the Spectator The Edition: Labour turns on Starmer – inside the collapse, with Guto Harri, Tim Shipman & Toby Young
4 snips
Feb 13, 2026 Tim Shipman, veteran political editor known for insider reporting; Guto Harri, former Downing Street communications chief; Toby Young, columnist and commentator. They unpack how Keir Starmer’s leadership unravelled, the claustrophobic Downing Street culture, possible Labour successors, Kemi Badenoch’s resurgence, royal transparency after Epstein files, toy-collecting adults, a new Wuthering Heights take, and the politics of hair.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Outsourcing The First 100 Days
- Starmer's team outsourced early governing plans to Sue Gray but expected civil service steadiness rather than political direction.
- That mismatch left political aides sidelined and Whitehall in control without a visible mission.
Al Karnes' Rugged Image
- Tim describes Alok Sharma's colleague Alok Karnes as a rugged ex-Royal Marine who posts pub photos and pull-up competitions.
- He suggests Karnes projects the kind of leadership image some MPs crave as an alternative to Starmer.
Shabana Mahmood's Electability Edge
- Shipman says Shabana Mahmood is viewed as the most able cabinet minister and broadly mainstream on migration.
- He notes her lack of support from the soft left limits her leadership prospects despite cross-party appeal.






