The Athletic FC Podcast Are football's new laws overcomplicating the game?
Mar 7, 2026
Mark Carey, football writer and analyst, and Michael Cox, tactical journalist famed for deep game analysis. They dissect VAR's expanded remit, countdowns for throw-ins and restarts, substitution and treatment timing tweaks, Wenger's offside trial and offside technicalities. They also debate coach challenge proposals and how IFAB shapes rule changes.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
VAR's Expanded Role Targets Quick Clear Errors
- IFAB extended VAR to correct clear errors like mistaken identity and clearly incorrect second yellow cards to protect match integrity.
- Panel welcomed quick, limited reviews designed to be resolved within seconds, not lengthy VAR stoppages.
Disagreement Over VAR For Corners
- The panel split on allowing VAR to review incorrectly awarded corners, with Duncan uneasy about widening VAR into many marginal events.
- Michael argued single replay fixes are often obvious, but Duncan warned of cascading appeals and delays.
Coach Challenges Could Tilt Power Off The Pitch
- IFAB is trialing a coach's challenge alternative to full VAR, but guests worry it shifts power to coaches and risks tactical gamesmanship.
- Michael and Mark prefer captain-led or independent review to avoid sideline influence and crowd pressure.