The Herd with Colin Cowherd THE HERD - Hour 2 - College QBs in the playoffs, thoughts on Ty Simpson declaring for the draft, Todd McShay
Jan 7, 2026
NFL Draft analyst Todd McShay, renowned for his expertise in evaluating prospects, joins to dissect the college quarterbacks in the playoffs. He breaks down Ty Simpson's draft potential and the critical importance of landing spots for QBs in the NFL. The conversation touches on John Harbaugh's unexpected firing and the ideal coaching candidates for the Ravens. McShay also provides insights into Miami's playoff readiness and the impact of Saban's coaching tree on the semifinal matchups.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Ravens Are An Elite Coaching Job
- Colin Cowherd argues the Ravens job is 'almost perfect' due to ownership, cap, and a star QB.
- He says Baltimore needs an offensive coach to make Lamar happy, not a culture creator.
Ty Simpson: Talent Vs. Experience
- Todd McShay sees Ty Simpson as a first-round talent despite limited traits like size or arm.
- He warns Simpson's lack of college experience (15 starts) makes his NFL outcome landing-spot dependent.
Prioritize Landing Spot Over Immediate Play
- Colin Cowherd and Todd McShay advise that landing spot shapes quarterback careers more than raw talent.
- They recommend quarterbacks sit a year in the right system rather than start immediately on a bad team.