The Story Trump has a new plan for 'eternal peace' in Gaza. But does either side want it?
Oct 1, 2025
Gabrielle Weiniger, The Times' correspondent in Tel Aviv, delves into the newly announced 20-point peace plan between Trump and Netanyahu. She outlines key elements like a long-term truce and hostage exchanges, while discussing the reactions from hardliners on both sides. With Netanyahu's ultimatum hanging over Hamas, she explores the political risks for Israel’s leadership and the mixed sentiments of both Israelis and Palestinians. Additionally, Gabrielle shares insights on potential governance for Gaza and the challenges that lie ahead for peace.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Ultimatum Undercuts Negotiating Space
- Netanyahu publicly signalled Israel could resume full military action if Hamas doesn't accept terms quickly.
- That ultimatum raises the risk the plan is presented more as leverage than a sincere negotiated pathway.
Staged Withdrawal Masks Long-Term Control
- The deal envisions a staged Israeli withdrawal with Israel retaining security control and potential corridors under its influence.
- Vague terms let Israel justify prolonged presence citing security needs.
No Annexation Pledge Faces Political Resistance
- The plan formally rules out annexation and Jewish settlements in Gaza, but Netanyahu's past actions and rhetoric create uncertainty.
- Previous ceasefires collapsed when Netanyahu refused to proceed to follow-up diplomatic phases.