LessWrong (Curated & Popular)

"No, we haven’t uploaded a fly yet" by Ariel Zeleznikow-Johnston

19 snips
Mar 21, 2026
A viral demo claimed a fruit fly had been uploaded, sparking scrutiny over what was actually shown. The episode traces the history of Drosophila connectomics and existing brain and body models. It explains what Eon Systems integrated, why the demo may overstate the brain’s role, and why loosening the term upload risks hype and misdirected funding.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Viral Visuals Don't Prove An Upload

  • Viral demos can mislead: a convincing video isn't proof of a full brain upload.
  • Eon’s demo paired a connectome-derived model with prebuilt controllers, so visuals overstate causal equivalence to a biological fly.
ANECDOTE

Community Backlash After Bold Upload Claim

  • Eon claimed on X and in a follow-up blog that they 'uploaded a fruit fly', thanking numerous labs and advisors.
  • Neuroscientists reacted angrily, calling for publications and accusing Eon of misleading conduct.
INSIGHT

Several 2024 Advances Made The Demo Possible

  • Progress enabled the demo: Flywire's 2024 complete connectome plus Shu et al.'s brain model and NeuromechFly V2 body made integration possible.
  • These separate advances each capture different aspects: wiring, simplified neuron dynamics, and biomechanical controllers.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app