Can Carney Break Canada's High Speed Rail Curse?

12 snips

Mar 31, 2026

Guest

Andrew Hyett

Andrew Hyett, geotechnical researcher, explains soils, water and winter engineering risks. Lindsay Davidson, physician and technical analyst, probes environmental and process concerns. Katie Koopman, South Frontenac resident and organizer, describes community disruption and organizing. They discuss route choices, local resistance, consultation gaps, and the technical hurdles of a 1,000 km high-speed rail plan.

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Transcript

Episode notes

ANECDOTE

South Frontenac Resident Finds Her Home In The Purple Corridor

Katie Koopman discovered Alto's purple corridor on January 17 and found her South Frontenac property inside a 10 km wide study zone.
Her reaction: joining/leading Save South Frontenac and managing widespread local anxiety and 13,000+ Facebook group members.

INSIGHT

Purple Haze Means Potential Expropriation Not Just A Draft Map

Alto's purple haze is a 10 km wide, ~1,000 km long corridor under study, not a final route, but within it properties could be expropriated.
Expropriation power lies with government/Crown corporations, meaning owners have limited ability to stop land takings.

ANECDOTE

Two Route Options Threaten Different Rural Communities

Communities face two route options near Peterborough: a northern Highway 7 corridor or a southern route dipping through Sterling and Campbellford near South Frontenac.
Katie fears the southern option would cut through her township and disrupt local roads and land use.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

Mark Carney has proposed a 1,000-kilometre high-speed rail line connecting Toronto to Quebec City, with trains reaching speeds of up to 300 km/h. It would be Canada’s first true high-speed rail system. On paper, the idea is appealing. But building it is far from straightforward.

Host Noor Azrieh, tries to answer the question: how do you build ambitious, nation-shaping infrastructure in a country where the human realities on the ground are so complex?

Host: Noor Azrieh

Credits: Aviva Lessard (Senior Producer), Sam Konnert (Host/Producer), Noor Azrieh (Host/Producer), Caleb Thompson (Audio Editor and Technical Producer), Max Collins (Director of Audio) Jesse Brown (Editor), Tony Wang (Artwork)

Guests: Katie Koopman, Lindsay Davidson, Andrew Hyett, Paul Langan, Conservative MP Philip Lawrence

Background reading:

Canada is getting high-speed rail
Alto's CEO answers questions about the high-speed rail project – CBC News
High-speed rail project connecting Toronto and Quebec City sparks backlash over cost, land use – The Globe and Mail
Local researchers fill information gap in high-speed rail debate – The Kingston Whig Standard
Chris Selley: More alarming numbers for Canada's high-speed rail fantasy – National Post

It’s crowd-finding time at Canadaland! Share this episode with three people or simply send them over to canadaland.com/share and we’ll help them get started with a starter pack of some of our favourite episodes.

Sponsors:

Visit fizz.ca to learn more about Fizz mobile and its long list of added-value features and activate a first plan using the referral code CAN40 to get 40$ off and 10GB of free data.

Article is offering our listeners $50 off your first purchase of $100 or more. To claim, visit article.com/canadaland and the discount will be automatically applied at checkout.

Did you know we have a monthly supporter exclusive show?

Last week, we asked you if you’ve ever fallen for fake news. I guess even our savvy, discerning audience isn’t infallible. You all had a lot to say! So this week on Off The Record, it’s time to talk about fake news.

If you want to hear that (or if you want to catch up on all the great episodes of Off The Record you’ve missed!) become a supporter at canadaland.com/join or call in on March 26th and we’ll give you a free month of Canadaland premium.

If you value this podcast, Support us! You’ll get premium access to all our shows ad free, including early releases and bonus content. You’ll also get our exclusive newsletter, discounts on merch, tickets to our live and virtual events, and more than anything, you’ll be a part of the solution to Canada’s journalism crisis, you’ll be keeping our work free and accessible to everybody.

Can't get enough Canadaland? Follow @Canadaland_Podcasts on Instagram for clips, announcements, explainers and more.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.