The Brian Lehrer Show Change is Coming for New York's Catholics
Dec 19, 2025
In a captivating discussion, Daniel Rober, associate professor and chair of Catholic Studies at Sacred Heart University, analyzes Ronald Hicks' appointment as the new Archbishop of New York. Hicks, known for his grassroots approach and focus on underrepresented communities, is compared to Cardinal Dolan, whose leadership was more media-centric. Rober explores Hicks' strong advocacy for immigration, potential as a unifying figure, and hopes for advancing women's roles within the church, all against the backdrop of significant moral and financial challenges facing the archdiocese.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Romero-Shaped Pastoral Vision
- Bishop Ronald Hicks draws deep inspiration from St. Oscar Romero and his work in El Salvador, shaping a ministry focused on marginalized people.
- His Spanish episcopal motto and emphasis on the Latino church signal pastoral priorities aligned with Pope Leo's style.
From Donor Focus To Grassroots Ministry
- Hicks prioritizes being "on the ground" with immigrants, the poor, and people who are afraid about their status in the city.
- That contrasts with Cardinal Dolan's media-friendly, donor-focused image and suggests a shift toward grassroots ministry.
Synodality And A Listening Leadership
- Hicks resembles Pope Leo in being attentive, listening, and comfortable with synodality and conversational church processes.
- He is likely more open to reform-minded practices than Cardinal Dolan, reflecting a different leadership temperament.