Christian History Almanac Thursday, February 19, 2026
Feb 19, 2026
A deep dive into the 1974 Lutheran split sparked by events at St. Louis Seminary. Traces the conflict back to earlier fundamentalist–modernist battles and postwar church mergers. Explores the walkout that created Seminex and how that controversy helped shape future Lutheran bodies. Places the conflict within 1960s–70s protest culture.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Unity Talks Raised Stakes For Doctrinal Tests
- Dan outlines how postwar Lutheran consolidation raised anxieties about theological conformity and potential union with other Lutheran bodies.
- He frames the 1973 convention decisions as procedural moves that escalated into personnel and doctrinal purges.
Biblical Criticism Fueled Denominational Conflict
- Dan links the LCMS conflict to wider mid-20th-century debates about modernism versus fundamentalism and biblical criticism.
- He shows how concerns over the historical-critical method precipitated denominational votes and doctrinal tests.
Seminex Walkout And Crosses In The Quad
- Dan van Voorhis recounts the dramatic 1974 St. Louis seminary walkout that created 'Seminex' and planted crosses while boarding the quad entrance.
- He explains that 40 of 45 professors and about 200 students left and later formed the AELC, influencing the ELCA's origins.