This American Life 884: The Idiot
48 snips
Mar 29, 2026 M. Gessen, journalist and author who investigates a true-crime family saga, recounts a personal story of kidnapping, undercover recordings, and a shocking turn toward murder-for-hire. Short scenes cover a charismatic cousin’s schemes, secret reporting to help a mother find her son, the FBI sting, trial recordings, and complex family reckonings.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Child Wellbeing Complicates Moral Judgments
- Despite ethical alarm, M. Gessen observed that O appeared thriving with Alan and Lena, complicating a simple victim-perpetrator view.
- The child attended Jewish school, violin, fencing, horseback riding and seemed happy, forcing nuanced reporting choices.
Kidnapping Arrest Became Family Spectacle
- Alan was arrested in Canada for taking O again; family treated the arrest like an absurd, cartoonish episode rather than immediate horror.
- Lena posted dramatic Facebook updates and Alan sang a Russian prison song, turning a serious charge into family theatre.
Backyard Camping Interrupted By Murder Arrest
- A July 2022 raid on M. Gessen's father's house resulted in Alan being taken by FBI for an alleged murder-for-hire plot targeting his ex-wife Priscilla.
- The arrest shattered family complacency, turning private dinners and camping trips into the backdrop for a criminal investigation.