NFL Daily with Gregg Rosenthal

Quarterback Island: Who are the 12 Defining QBs in the NFL?

14 snips
Oct 7, 2025
The team revisits the intriguing concept of Quarterback Island, debating which 12 QBs earn their spot. They discuss locked-in players and the fate of others like Burrow, Purdy, and Stroud. Excitement arises as Darnold and Maye gain inclusion, while Stafford and Jones make surprising appearances on the island. Following lively arguments, Hurts secures the last slot. The show wraps with a preview of the Eagles vs. Giants and a spirited analysis of the Ravens' trade for Odafe Oweh, exploring its impact on both teams.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Injury Rule Has Exceptions

  • The panel wrestles with an injury rule for island residency and treats Lamar Jackson as a special case due to elite pre-injury play.
  • They acknowledge rules can be flexible when a player's impact before injury was defining.
ANECDOTE

Sam Darnold Revival

  • Colleen nominates Sam Darnold based on his play and scheme fit in Seattle's balanced offense.
  • The panel agrees, noting Darnold ranks highly across advanced metrics early in 2025.
INSIGHT

Drake Maye Rapid Rise

  • Drake Maye's decisive play and adaptability earn rapid island consideration after standout performances.
  • His mix of passing accuracy and designed rush threat shifts opponent planning and opens playcalling.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app