First Things Podcast

Our Crisis is Metaphysical | 2026 D.C. Lecture | 2026 D.C. Lecture (Presented by: Mary Harrington)

Mar 19, 2026
Mary Harrington, author and journalist known for cultural criticism and Feminism Against Progress, presents a lecture on how modernity lost metaphysical categories. She explores motherhood’s invisibility, scholastic concepts like form and potency, the Pill’s technicizing of bodies, and warnings about AI and treating humans as rearrangeable matter. Calls for reclaiming language of form, telos, and the logos.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Missing Metaphysical Vocabulary Explains Current Blind Spots

  • Modern discourse lacks metaphysical vocabulary like act/potency and substance/accident, which explains gaps in debates about motherhood, sex, and development.
  • Mary Harrington found these tools in Aristotelian-Thomistic metaphysics and used them to explain mothering as pattern, interdependence, and normal developmental trajectories.
ANECDOTE

Becoming A Mother Revealed A Vocabulary Gap

  • Harrington recounts becoming a mother at 38 and the shock of embodiment that exposed vocabulary gaps about mothering and normal development.
  • That experience prompted her to search for concepts like patterns, interdependence, and developmental normalcy she couldn't name before.
INSIGHT

Scholastic Tools To Understand Human Form

  • Three scholastic tools clarify human nature: potency vs act, substance vs accident, and fourfold causality including final cause (telos).
  • These concepts let you distinguish what a thing can become, its essence, and its purpose, grounding arguments about sex and development.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app