The Herd with Colin Cowherd Best of The Herd
Jan 28, 2026
Jimmy Johnson, Pro Football Hall of Famer and TV analyst, weighs in on coaching legacy and Belichick’s credentials. Seth Wickersham, ESPN senior writer and bestselling author, explains Hall of Fame voting dynamics and reporting behind the scenes. They debate Spygate’s fallout, voting changes, and why a coaching legend missed first-ballot induction. Multiple lively takes and sharp context.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Brady's Impact On Belichick's Record
- Belichick's team performance depended heavily on Tom Brady, with a sharp drop in scoring and win rate without him.
- Colin argues voters can reasonably pause a year to weigh a coach whose success aligns so closely with one superstar QB.
Tarnished Super Bowl Week Matters
- Super Bowl week is the league's most valuable week and Spygate tarnished Belichick's reputation during that period.
- Colin says mistakes that hit peak-value moments create a lasting 'tax' on legacy and voter perception.
Eligibility Rule Change Shifted Expectations
- Voting methodology changed so coaches can be elected one year after leaving, while players still wait five years.
- Colin highlights that changing eligibility rules can shift expectations and produce surprising outcomes.