Best of the Spectator

The Book Club: The Rise of the Mafia and the Struggle for Italy’s Soul

11 snips
Feb 5, 2026
Caroline Moorhead, historian and author of A Sicilian Man, explores Leonardo Sciascia, Sicily and the rise of the mafia. She traces Sciascia’s use of detective fiction as social critique. They discuss Sicily’s distinct identity, the mafia’s historical roots and evolution, Sciascia’s political controversies, and his literary influences and legacy.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Invert The Detective Story

  • Sciascia inverted detective fiction: books often start knowing the perpetrator and focus on context and societal causes.
  • He used erudite, cultured investigators and Enlightenment references to deepen social critique.
INSIGHT

Feudal Roots To Modern Power

  • The Mafia grew from feudal-era middlemen (gabelloti) who enforced landlords' power and later entered urban construction and electoral politics.
  • That evolution tied organised crime to economic booms and vote delivery, embedding it in Sicily's political fabric.
INSIGHT

Palm Trees Creeping North

  • Sciascia warned the Mafia would spread north and into national politics, a prediction captured in his phrase about palm trees moving north.
  • He became Italy's go-to 'mafiologo' because his warnings repeatedly proved prescient.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app