Catholic Answers Live #12596 Can You Explain Papal Authority and Praying for the Dead? | Why Aren’t You Catholic? - Joe Heschmeyer
Feb 19, 2026
Joe Heschmeyer, Catholic apologist and historian of the early Church, explains complex questions in clear historical terms. He unpacks papal authority, the relationship between Vatican I and the Council of Constance. He also discusses the practice of praying for the dead and how Orthodox perspectives view Roman primacy.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
A Lifelong Tug Back To Catholicism
- Mike described returning to Catholic ideas after a lifelong journey through Protestantism and Calvinism.
- He traced a persistent tug from his infant baptism that now draws him back toward Catholicism.
Follow The Movement Toward Faith
- Cy encouraged Mike to follow the movement he feels toward Catholicism and keep investigating.
- He recommended combining a rigorous mind with a warm heart as a path into Catholic life.
2 Maccabees Presents Prayer For The Dead As Pious
- Joe argued 2 Maccabees 12 both describes and approves praying for the dead by calling Judas' action "holy and pious."
- That language implies prescription, not merely neutral description.
