EP 186 | Fallen Pastors & Sexual Sin: Why Good Theology Isn't Enough | Redeeming Truth

Jan 28, 2026

Ask episode

Chapters

Transcript

Episode notes

When pastors fall into sexual sin, adultery, or moral failure, the impact on churches, families, and individual believers can be devastating. In this episode of Redeeming Truth from Redeemer Bible Church, Pastor Jon Benzinger sits down with our pastors and biblical counselors to speak honestly about fallen pastors, pastoral disqualification, and how Christians can process betrayal while rebuilding trust in Christ—not in men.

Drawing from real-life stories of hidden sin, long-term affairs, and leaders disqualified from ministry, this conversation addresses:

Why sound theology—even Reformed doctrine—alone cannot keep a pastor from falling
How discontentment, lust, pride, and heart-level idolatry fuel secret sin
The ripple effects of pastoral failure on marriages, children, congregations, and communities
Why pastors are "but men" who need accountability, prayer, and close fellowship
How believers can grieve rightly while keeping their eyes fixed on Jesus

You'll also hear:

A sobering account of a large church shattered by a long-hidden affair
Counseling insights on trust, trauma, disillusionment, and church discipline
Biblical warnings from Luke 4:13; 1 Timothy 4:16; James 1; Romans 13, and more
Why discontentment often becomes the gateway sin to adultery and moral failure
Howard Hendricks' findings from thousands of fallen pastors—and what they all had stopped doing

If you've been hurt by a fallen pastor, fear it could happen where you worship, or are a pastor who wants to finish well, this episode offers sober warning, biblical clarity, and gospel hope.

🔔 Subscribe for more biblical teaching and pastoral conversations from Redeemer Bible Church.

💬 Share this episode with someone wrestling with church hurt or pastoral failure.

Click here to Subscribe to our channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCenfIkvDIJa4Qb4WgsH8hkw?sub_confirmation=1

REDEEMING TRUTH MEDIA: http://redeemingtruthmedia.org/

For more information about Redeemer Bible Church in Gilbert, Arizona, or to help support this ministry, please visit us at https://www.redeemeraz.org

Join our Facebook Group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/redeemeraz

Never miss a sermon, find our Redeeming Truth Podcast in your favorite player, and subscribe!