The Herd with Colin Cowherd 3 & Out - Browns found their "filler" coach, Why McCarthy gets no respect, Mailbag
Jan 29, 2026
They debate Cleveland’s hire of Todd Monken as a likely short-term, stopgap coach and why top candidates shied away. A spirited defense of Bill Belichick’s legacy and critiques of Hall of Fame voters come up. They dig into Mike McCarthy’s reputation problem and whether coaching resumes get the respect they deserve. Rapid-fire mailbag topics range from coaching hires to parenting tips.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Browns Hire Feels Like A Bridge
- The Browns hiring Todd Monken feels like a temporary 'bridge' move rather than a long-term solution.
- John Middlecoff says Cleveland likely aims to steady the roster and search for a true long-term coach and QB.
Belichick Snub Hurts The Hall
- Bill Belichick not earning first-ballot Hall of Fame support damages the institution's credibility.
- Middlecoff argues the vote reflects herd mentality and undermines the Hall's legitimacy.
McCarthy's Reputation Versus Reality
- Mike McCarthy is undervalued due to branding, not résumé.
- Middlecoff says McCarthy's strengths as an offensive QB coach match peers like Tomlin and Harbaugh despite perception issues.