How Did This Get Made? Toys w/ Drew McWeeny (Classic)
Dec 9, 2025
Join film critic Drew McWeeny, known for his insightful commentary, as he explores the chaotic world of the 1992 film Toys alongside hosts Paul and Jason. They dissect Robin Williams' perplexing performance and the film's surreal visuals, influenced by Magritte. The discussion also highlights bizarre scenes, questionable character choices involving Joan Cusack, and the inconsistent tone that swings between comedy and drama. Plus, don’t miss the oddities of the final battle and the unidentified sea monster that leaves everyone scratching their heads!
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Tone Whiplash Undermines Impact
- The film oscillates between comedy and drama without committing to either.
- That tone whiplash undermines both humor and emotional engagement.
Robin Williams' Creepy Childlike Arc
- Paul and Jason recall Robin Williams' character behaving childlike yet sexually active.
- The juxtaposition made the film feel creepy rather than charming to them.
Design Can't Fix Plot Holes
- Strong production design can’t hide narrative gaps.
- Beautiful Magritte-inspired visuals highlight how much the script fails to justify the world.
