That's So Criminal Finding Nancy Guthrie: The DNA Chase - Ep. 12
Feb 18, 2026
DNA on a glove linked to Nancy Guthrie’s case has been tested and drew no CODIS match, prompting further genealogical analysis. Investigators are recovering deleted doorbell video and canvassing neighbor footage. Conflicting statements from law enforcement and new items found at the scene have raised questions. A $100,000 reward has been offered to encourage tips and renew public interest.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Genetic Genealogy Is Now In Play
- DNA from a glove found two miles from Nancy Guthrie's home didn't match CODIS, so investigators escalated to genetic genealogy testing.
- The FBI is building family trees from the unknown profile to identify the glove's owner through shared DNA.
Confusing Official Messaging
- Pima County's messaging about the Guthrie family has been inconsistent across statements and press releases.
- Lyndon Blake flags that “not been identified as suspects” differs from earlier “cleared as possible suspects,” raising questions about clarity.
Blue Shirt And Lax Scene Control
- A blue shirt left near Nancy's front porch was confirmed to belong to Nancy and was reportedly left by a searcher after a canine sweep.
- Lyndon Blake expresses frustration that basic scene management allowed food and packages at the property.