Sed Contra: A Podcast of Catholic Theology

Quodlibet 20: Should the Church Promote Only One Theological School?

Feb 19, 2026
They ask whether the Church should endorse a single theological school and unpack why multiple schools persist. They wrestle with animal intelligence and how Thomistic views of the soul respond to new science. They swap favorite nonfiction reads, debate whether 'niceness' equals virtue, and reflect on deliberation, reflexivity, and what truly distinguishes human love from animal affection.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
ANECDOTE

Podcast Revives Medieval Open Question Tradition

  • The Quaelibets format revives medieval open-question sessions where anyone could ask about anything.
  • Taylor Patrick O'Neill and Matthew Duganzik invite listeners to submit questions by email and answer a wide variety live on the show.
ANECDOTE

Hosts Share Memorable Snow Experiences

  • Matthew and Taylor trade personal snow stories: kayaking down a street, snow thunder, power outages, and family snow activities.
  • These stories illustrate regional differences in winter culture and set a casual tone before theological questions.
INSIGHT

Niceness Can Be Context Dependent

  • Niceness is an external set of behaviors that can be virtuous or misleading depending on intention and context.
  • Matthew contrasts Midwestern niceness with New York politeness: short, efficient interactions can be more courteous in dense settings.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app