Open Source with Christopher Lydon Fear and Fury
Mar 26, 2026
Heather Ann Thompson, historian and Pulitzer Prize–winning author of work on prison history, digs into the Bernie Goetz subway shootings and their place in 1980s America. She traces how fear, media narratives, and political shifts normalized vigilantism. Short, sharp takes on race, urban decline, conservative media, and the rebirth of white rage.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Two Worlds Collide On The IRT Train
- The subway shooting fused two socioeconomic worlds: an ordinary white resident resentful of visible urban decline and four South Bronx teenagers surviving austerity-era scarcity.
- Thompson names the teenagers Daryl Cabe, James Ramseur, Troy Canty, and Barry Allen to rehumanize those erased by sensational headlines.
How The Shooting Unfolded On The Train
- On the 2 train Goetz shot four youths after one asked him for $5; he admitted the intent to kill during his confession.
- Passengers watched as he shot at close range, then escaped into the subway for nine days before turning himself in.
Verdict Shows A Shift Toward Legalizing Vigilante Rage
- Despite Goetz's full confession and eyewitness accounts, a jury accepted a self-defense framing and convicted him only on gun charges.
- Thompson views that verdict as symbolic of a larger cultural shift: public perception and law could be reshaped to validate vigilante violence.
