Buried Bones - a historical true crime podcast with Kate Winkler Dawson and Paul Holes The Falls Field Tragedy
27 snips
Feb 11, 2026 A 1850s Rochester river recovery uncovers a second, mysterious body and a strange weapon. Physical clues on the bank and worn household items tie suspects to the scene. Rumors of affairs, family secrets, and a possible incestuous scandal swirl through town. A controversial trial, public campaigns for clemency, and last statements reshape the case's legacy.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Victim Was A Prominent, Troubled Attorney
- The victim was identified quickly as 25-year-old attorney Charles Littles, known for affairs and heavy drinking.
- His marital troubles and reputation expanded the suspect pool to family, lovers, and business contacts.
Family Criminal History Increases Scrutiny
- Family history and prior crimes shaped suspicion: Ira and his father had forgery, burglary and arson backgrounds.
- Paul highlights how a suspect’s criminal history elevates them in investigators' suspect pools.
Female Items Could Be Staging Or Evidence
- Personal items from a woman (rosette, combs, squirrel tail) at the scene suggested a female presence or staging.
- Paul notes such deposits could be deliberate staging to implicate a woman like Sarah.
