The Moynihan Report

Why did New York City’s murder rate plummet? | The Moynihan Report

12 snips
Aug 21, 2025
Joining Michael Moynihan is Peter Moskos, a former police officer and professor known for his insights on NYC policing. They explore the dramatic drop in the city's murder rate since the 1990s, revealing the impact of broken windows policing and community engagement. Peter shares his unique perspective on traditional and modern policing strategies, the role of political leadership, and the challenges facing law enforcement today. Their candid discussion also touches on social perceptions of safety and the complexities of community dynamics in policing.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
ANECDOTE

Open Gates Today, Arrests Then

  • Michael Moynihan recounts seeing subway gates left open and guards letting people through despite paid contracts.
  • He contrasts this with 1990s enforcement when fare evasion led to arrests and discoveries of warrants and guns.
INSIGHT

Comstat's Power Was Accountability, Not Tech

  • Comstat moved from pin maps to rapid data; its real value was accountability and faster problem-solving.
  • The tech was simple but forced precinct commanders to plan and be answerable for crime.
ADVICE

Beware Perverse Metrics

  • Avoid incentivizing easy numeric targets that warp behavior, like counting stops as productivity.
  • Use stable, meaningful metrics (murders/shootings) to track public safety progress.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app