The McShay Show Mock Draft 2.0: Mendoza Trade Offers, Reese’s NFL Comp, and More Round 1 Takeaways
Feb 9, 2026
A Mock Draft breakdown of the top 16 picks, highlighting surprising selections and ideal landing spots. Debate over a potential Raiders trade and whether tackles or quarterbacks should go early. Analysis of hybrid linebacker fits, breakout edge rushers, and the strengths of the receiver class. Quick takes on medical questions, combine watchlist names, and toughest positions to evaluate.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Mendoza's Mental Edge
- Fernando Mendoza projects as a high-character, obsessive processor who improved drastically under Kurt Signetti's staff.
- Todd McShay argues that his mental traits make him an attractive potential No.1 pick despite not being the flashiest athlete.
Think Twice Before Trading No.1
- Trading the No.1 pick would require a massive haul and conviction because 2027's class could be historically strong.
- McShay warns giving up next year's picks for a 2026 player risks extreme short-sightedness.
Don't Sacrifice 2027 For 2026
- Avoid trading future (2027) compensation for 2026 picks unless the return decisively outweighs next year's class.
- McShay explicitly cautions teams not to surrender next-year assets for marginal short-term gain.