BibleThinker James Talarico's crazy Gospel of Thomas teaching: 10 Qs with Mike Winger (Ep 72)
50 snips
Mar 20, 2026 A critique of James Talarico’s use of the Gospel of Thomas and why that text’s secretive, Gnostic traits worry some Christians. Examination of odd sayings, exclusivist language, and problematic gender ideas in Thomas. A long Q and A covers converting from Judaism, walking by the Spirit, elders versus denominational boards, James versus Paul on justification, fear about teaching, purity culture, and how to discern real miracles.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Thomas Requires Women To 'Become Male'
- Winger reads Thomas 114 where Jesus supposedly says women must 'make themselves male' to enter the kingdom, showing its anti-woman and bizarre anthropology.
- He points out this contradicts apostolic teaching on gender roles.
How A Jewish Believer Should Share Faith Wisely
- Do move forward with baptism and be patient and reserved when sharing faith with a rabbinic or secular Jewish family.
- Listen, gather objections, research answers (e.g., Michael Brown's series) and respond humbly rather than rushing declarations.
Practical Ways To Walk By The Spirit
- Do set your mind on the Spirit by choosing to pursue God and by practicing godly behaviors daily.
- Winger recommends intentional habits: Scripture reading, church attendance, service, prayer — practical actions that cultivate spiritual mindset.
