Best of the Spectator The Edition: Benefits Britain, mental health & what’s the greatest artwork of the 21st Century?
Dec 5, 2025
Matthew Parris, a sharp political commentator known for his reflections on mental health, joins Rupert Hawksley, opinion editor at The Spectator, and Igor Toronyi-Lalic, arts editor, for a thought-provoking discussion. They dive into the implications of Labour's welfare increasing budget and explore the artistic value of an inefficient state. The trio also debates the greatest artwork of the 21st century, sharing perspectives on everything from television shows to impactful music. Finally, they pay tribute to the late Tom Stoppard, revealing his lasting influence on culture.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Arts Thrive On An Inefficient State
- Igor Toronyi-Lalic argues artists benefit from a profligate, inefficient state that leaves room for creative risk.
- He prefers a leaky state over an efficient, controlling one because it fosters artistic flourishing.
Mental Health Is A Sliding Scale
- Mental health and rationality exist on a sliding spectrum rather than fixed categories, complicating diagnosis and policy.
- Both Matthew Parris and Rupert Hawksley warn lumping mild and severe cases together harms those who could work.
Personal Stories Of Severe Illness
- Matthew Parris recounts a friend's partner who suffered seven years with ME and then recovered suddenly after violent fits.
- He also recounts his cousin Sally's suicide to illustrate the reality and tragedy of serious mental illness.
