Dive into the intriguing world of cost estimation with the Congressional Budget Office. Discover how they assess potential legislation, including a massive $400 billion drug subsidy for seniors, often without knowing the final product. Explore the complexities seniors face with insurance premiums and how their behavior influences market dynamics. Finally, uncover the challenges of forecasting drug prices and the legislative tensions that shape healthcare coverage, illustrating the delicate balancing act of predicting the future.
24:20
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
question_answer ANECDOTE
Post Office Renamings
The CBO often handles simple tasks like renaming post offices.
Doug Holzt-Eakin noted almost 20% of enacted legislation involved these renamings during his tenure.
insights INSIGHT
CBO's True Purpose
The CBO's most crucial work involves pricing unprecedented legislation.
This requires imagining non-existent markets and predicting future costs, which Doug Holzt-Eakin finds enjoyable.
question_answer ANECDOTE
Medicare's Drug Gap
In the early 2000s, seniors lacked prescription drug coverage under Medicare.
This created a risky market for private insurers due to the potential for high costs from sick individuals.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
If you are a congressperson or a senator and you have an idea for a new piece of legislation, at some point someone will have to tell you how much it costs. But, how do you put a price on something that doesn't exist yet?
Since 1974, that has been the job of the Congressional Budget Office, or the CBO. The agency plays a critical role in the legislative process: bills can live and die by the cost estimates the CBO produces.
The economists and budget experts at the CBO, though, are far more than just a bunch of number crunchers. Sometimes, when the job is really at its most fun, they are basically tasked with predicting the future. The CBO has to estimate the cost of unreleased products and imagine markets that don't yet exist — and someone always hates the number they come up with.
On today's episode, we go inside the CBO to tell the twisting tale behind the pricing of a single piece of massive legislation — when the U.S. decided to finally cover prescription drug insurance for seniors. At the time, some of the drugs the CBO was trying to price didn't even exist yet. But the CBO still had to tell Congress how much the bill would cost — even though the agency knew better than anyone that its math would almost definitely be wrong.
We want to hear your thoughts on the show! We have a short, anonymous survey we'd love for you to fill out: n.pr/pmsurvey
Planet Money