In Our Time On Liberty
Piers Norris Turner, Associate Professor of Philosophy at Ohio State, unpacks Mill’s arguments. Helen McCabe, Professor of Political Theory at Nottingham, traces Mill’s life and Harriet Taylor’s role. Mark Philp, Emeritus Professor of History and Politics at Warwick, situates Mill in 19th-century politics. They debate the harm principle, tyranny of opinion, individuality as social progress, and who counts as fit for liberty.
49:24
Tyranny Of Public Opinion
- Mill (with Harriet Taylor) warns that social pressure and public opinion can stifle individuality and social progress.
- They argue diversity of individual experiments in living is essential for societal strength and improvement.
Mill's Personal Breakdown And Recovery
- John Stuart Mill endured a severe mental crisis in his mid-20s when utilitarian goals stopped giving him joy.
- He recovered by reconnecting with emotion, nature, music and developing interests beyond strict rationalism.
Harm Principle As A Limit On Interference
- Mill and Harriet developed the harm principle: society may only interfere to prevent harm to others.
- This limits both legal coercion and social pressure, protecting individual choices and diversity.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app 1 chevron_right 2 chevron_right 3 chevron_right 4 chevron_right 5 chevron_right 6 chevron_right 7 chevron_right 8 chevron_right 9 chevron_right 10 chevron_right 11 chevron_right 12 chevron_right 13 chevron_right 14 chevron_right 15 chevron_right 16 chevron_right 17 chevron_right 18 chevron_right 19 chevron_right 20 chevron_right 21 chevron_right
Intro
00:00 • 1min
Mill's childhood and rigorous education
01:18 • 1min
Bentham's influence and utilitarian roots
02:45 • 4min
Mill's mental crisis and recovery
06:23 • 3min
Meeting Harriet Taylor and their partnership
09:23 • 2min
Defining liberticide and threats to liberty
11:25 • 2min
Purpose and structure of On Liberty
13:29 • 1min
Harriet Taylor's co-authorship claim
14:30 • 2min
Societal pressures and conformity worries
16:34 • 2min
Understanding Mill's harm principle
18:57 • 1min
Ad break
20:18 • 2min
Value of individuality and experiments in living
22:02 • 3min
Defense of free thought and expression
24:37 • 3min
Is On Liberty unfinished and why it matters
27:16 • 3min
Interpreting limits: what counts as harm
29:56 • 2min
Applicability to 'barbarous' and other societies
31:31 • 2min
European context and cross-fertilisation
34:00 • 2min
Reception and lasting influence
35:39 • 2min
On Liberty as foundational liberal text
37:11 • 1min
Mill's pluralist optimism and elitism tension
38:37 • 3min
Outro
41:53 • 11min
#35194
A Moralist In and Out of Parliament: John Stuart Mill at Westminster, 1865-1868
Ann P. Robson
Bruce L. Kinzer
John M. Robson
This book examines John Stuart Mill's tenure in the British Parliament from 1865 to 1868, placing his political and personal beliefs in the context of major reforms and the polarization between Liberals and Conservatives.
It highlights Mill's radical reform efforts, egalitarian motivations, successes, and failures during this watershed period.
The study draws on Mill's speeches, votes, and correspondence to analyze his role as a moralist in and out of Parliament.
#42593
On Liberty, Utilitarianism and Other Essays
Frederick Rosen
John Stuart Mill
Mark Philp
Mill's four essays, 'On Liberty', 'Utilitarianism', 'Considerations on Representative Government', and 'The Subjection of Women' examine central issues facing liberal democratic regimes, including individual liberty, ethical principles, representative institutions and gender equality.
The introduction by Mark Philp and Frederick Rosen contextualizes the essays within Mill's works, emphasizing his focus on human character development as core to liberalism.
These essays have shaped Western political institutions since the late nineteenth century.
#90964
A Companion to Mill
The Cambridge Companion to Mill
Christopher Macleod
Dale E. Miller
This Companion provides a state-of-the-art overview of John Stuart Mill's work, including historical influences, theoretical foundations, moral and social philosophy, and connections to modern debates.
Divided into six parts, it explores Mill's life, intellectual influences, epistemology, metaphysics, liberty, utilitarianism, and broader philosophical relations.
Contributors are leading scholars offering essential resources for understanding Mill's thought.
#68437
J.S. Mill's Political Thought: A Bicentennial Reassessment
Nadia Urbinati
Alex Zakaras
This volume illustrates the breadth and depth of John Stuart Mill's political writings, exploring underappreciated elements of his philosophy.
It addresses democratic institutions and culture, liberalism, and international politics, offering a critical reassessment in light of recent developments.
Essays by contributors like Nadia Urbinati and Alex Zakaras examine tensions in Mill's views on despotism, individuality, participatory democracy, and state-building.
#54963
Mill on liberty
C. L. Ten
This book provides a sympathetic yet critical analysis of Mill's On Liberty, maintaining the general consistency and coherence of Mill's arguments for individual liberty while identifying significant non-utilitarian elements.
It explores key conceptual issues raised by the essay through a philosophical lens.
#87868
John Stuart Mill's autobiography
John Stuart Mill
John Stuart Mill's 'Autobiography' chronicles his intellectual and personal development, offering insights into his philosophical and political beliefs.
Mill recounts his rigorous upbringing, shaped by his father's utilitarian principles, and his subsequent intellectual crisis that led him to question those principles.
The autobiography explores his evolving views on individual liberty, social reform, and the importance of intellectual diversity.
Mill reflects on his relationships, including his profound intellectual partnership with Harriet Taylor.
The book provides a valuable perspective on the 19th-century intellectual landscape and the shaping of Mill's influential contributions to liberal thought.
#35055
The Philosophy of John Stuart Mill
Alan Ryan
Alan Ryan's book provides an accessible and insightful analysis of John Stuart Mill's philosophical contributions, including his defense of utilitarianism, the harm principle in On Liberty, and advocacy for individual freedom and women's rights.
It examines Mill's empiricism, rejection of a priori knowledge, and emphasis on promoting the greatest happiness.
The work situates Mill's ideas within 19th-century thought, highlighting their enduring influence on ethics, politics, and society.
#86881
Harriet Taylor Mill
Helen McCabe
Harriet Taylor Mill is an overlooked figure in the history of political philosophy, ethics, economics, and politics, overshadowed by her husband John Stuart Mill.
This Element charts her input into famous works like On Liberty, analyzing her works and Mill's through close textual study, including unpublished manuscripts and correspondence, while examining their co-authoring relationship.
It covers topics such as liberty, marriage, gender, women's rights, socialism, morality, and religion.
#33715
• Mentioned in 2 episodes
John Stuart Mill, Socialist
Helena McCabe
#55896
Mill
Frederick Rosen
Frederick Rosen presents a comprehensive analysis of John Stuart Mill's moral and political thought, reassessing his philosophy through hermeneutic insights from Mill's System of Logic and Principles of Political Economy.
The book examines key themes in Mill's works, offering a fresh interpretation of his contributions to utilitarianism and liberalism.
#304
• Mentioned in 87 episodes
On liberty
John Stuart Mill
Published in 1859, 'On Liberty' is a seminal work by John Stuart Mill that argues for the protection of individual freedoms from the tyranny of the majority and government interference.
Mill uses utilitarian philosophy to justify the value of liberty, emphasizing the importance of freedom of thought, discussion, and action.
He introduces the 'harm principle,' which states that individuals should only be restrained from acting when their conduct may harm others.
The essay is structured into five chapters, each addressing different aspects of liberty, including the liberty of thought and discussion, individual liberty, the limits of authority, and practical applications of his theories.
Mill argues that protecting individual liberties is essential for societal progress and the avoidance of social stagnation.
#304
• Mentioned in 87 episodes
On liberty
John Stuart Mill
Published in 1859, 'On Liberty' is a seminal work by John Stuart Mill that argues for the protection of individual freedoms from the tyranny of the majority and government interference.
Mill uses utilitarian philosophy to justify the value of liberty, emphasizing the importance of freedom of thought, discussion, and action.
He introduces the 'harm principle,' which states that individuals should only be restrained from acting when their conduct may harm others.
The essay is structured into five chapters, each addressing different aspects of liberty, including the liberty of thought and discussion, individual liberty, the limits of authority, and practical applications of his theories.
Mill argues that protecting individual liberties is essential for societal progress and the avoidance of social stagnation.
#250
• Mentioned in 98 episodes
Democracy in America
Alexis de Tocqueville
Written after his travels in the United States, 'Democracy in America' is a comprehensive study of American society and government.
Tocqueville examines the democratic revolution and its impact on American life, discussing topics such as the sovereignty of the people, the role of civil society, the dangers of the tyranny of the majority, and the influence of religion and individualism.
The book is a philosophical and political analysis that aims to understand why republican representative democracy succeeded in the United States while failing in other places, and it offers insights into the future of democracy both in America and globally.
#1291
• Mentioned in 31 episodes
Autobiography
Benjamin Franklin
The Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin is a seminal work that spans several decades of Franklin's life, from his childhood in Boston to his later years as a respected statesman and scientist.
The autobiography is divided into four parts, each written during different periods of his life.
It covers his apprenticeship to his brother James, his early career as a printer and publisher, his experiments with electricity, and his civic and political involvements.
The work is notable for its insights into Franklin's personal life, his pursuit of moral perfection, and his contributions to American history and culture.
#51718
The Complete Works
Michel de Montaigne
Michel de Montaigne's "Essays" are a collection of personal reflections on a wide range of topics, including life, death, friendship, and self-knowledge.
Written in the 16th century, these essays are remarkable for their honesty, introspection, and intellectual depth.
Montaigne's willingness to share his vulnerabilities and doubts makes his work relatable and engaging even centuries later.
His essays are characterized by their digressive style and their exploration of the complexities of human experience.
The "Essays" remain a cornerstone of Western literature, offering timeless insights into the human condition.
Journalist, author and historian Misha Glenny presents his first edition of In Our Time, succeeding Melvyn Bragg who retired from this role last summer. Misha and his guests discuss the landmark work On Liberty by John Stuart Mill, published in 1859 and the increasing recognition for his wife Harriet Taylor Mill's contribution. The subject matter of the essay is ‘civil or social liberty: the nature and limits of the power which can be legitimately exercised by society over the individual’ and it argues that the sole end for which mankind may interfere with the liberty of action of anyone is self-protection and even then only to prevent harm to others. This essay became enormously popular and a foundational text for liberalism.
With
Helen McCabe Professor of Political Theory at the University of Nottingham
Mark Philp Emeritus Professor of History and Politics at the University of Warwick
And
Piers Norris Turner Associate Professor of Philosophy at The Ohio State University
Producer: Simon Tillotson
Reading list:
Jo Ellen Jacobs (ed.), Harriet Taylor Mill, Complete Works (Indiana University Press, 1998)
Bruce L. Kinzer, Ann P. Robson and John M. Robson, A Moralist In and Out of Parliament: John Stuart Mill at Westminster, 1865-1868 (University of Toronto Press, 1992) Christopher Macleod and Dale Miller (eds.), A Companion to Mill (Wiley, 2016)
Helen McCabe, John Stuart Mill, Socialist (McGill-Queen’s University Press, 2021)
Helen McCabe, Harriet Taylor Mill (Cambridge, 2023)
Piers Norris Turner, ‘The Arguments of On Liberty: Mill’s Institutional Designs’ (Nineteenth-Century Prose 47 (1), 2020)
Piers Norris Turner et al (eds.), John Stuart Mill and Harriet Taylor Mill, On Liberty with Related Writings (Hackett Publishing, forthcoming 2026)
Mark Philp (ed.), John Stuart Mill: Autobiography (Oxford University Press, 2018)
Mark Philp and Frederick Rosen (eds.), John Stuart Mill: On Liberty, Utilitarianism and other Essays (Oxford University Press, 2015)
Frederick Rosen, Mill (Oxford University Press, 2013)
Alan Ryan, The Philosophy of John Stuart Mill (Palgrave MacMillan, 1998)
Ben Saunders, ‘Reformulating Mill’s Harm Principle’ (Mind 125/500, 2016)
John Skorupski, Why Read Mill Today? (Routledge, 2006)
William Stafford, John Stuart Mill (Red Globe Press, 1998)
C. L. Ten (ed.), Mill: On Liberty: A Critical Guide (Cambridge University Press, 2008)
Nadia Urbinati and Alex Zakaras (eds.), John Stuart Mill’s Political Thought: A Bicentennial Reassessment (Cambridge University Press, 2007)
In Our Time is a BBC Studios production