Character, Policy, and Christian Principles for Voting, with David French

When it comes to voting, how should we balance character and policy?

"If I'm voting for a politician," journalist David French suggests, "I have a test. One is: Do they have the character necessary for the job? And the higher the position they're seeking, the more character that is necessary. And number two: Do they broadly agree with me on the most important policies?"

In this episode, Mark Labberton welcomes journalist David French (opinion columnist for the New York Times; formerly The Atlantic, The Dispatch, and National Review) for a discussion of character, policy, and principles for faithful, virtuous engagement in polarized American politics.

French's commitment to Christian faith, moral character, and reasoned policy has emerged from his experience as a former commercial lawyer, military lawyer, and former president of the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression. A political conservative, French has throughout his career been an advocate for First Amendment rights, pro-life individuals and organizations, and the ideals of democracy. He describes himself as "an evangelical conservative who believes strongly in a classical liberal, pluralistic vision of American democracy."

Together, Mark and David discuss his Christian upbringing; his personal partisan commitments; the importance of character in party politics; the importance of nuanced and reasoned policy; why he's voting for Kamala Harris in order to save conservative politics; two Bible verses for this election season; how to respond to our culture of fear; and how to secure a more courageous, loving, and humble politics.

About David French

David French is an opinion columnist for the New York Times, and previously wrote for The Atlantic, The Dispatch, and National Review. He is a New York Times bestselling author of Divided We Fall: America's Secession Threat and How to Restore Our Nation.

He describes himself as "an evangelical conservative who believes strongly in a classical liberal, pluralistic vision of American democracy."

He is a graduate of Harvard Law School, the past president of the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, and a former lecturer at Cornell Law School. He has served as a senior counsel for the American Center for Law and Justice and the Alliance Defending Freedom. David is a former major in the United States Army Reserve. In 2007, he deployed to Iraq, serving in Diyala Province as Squadron Judge Advocate for the 2nd Squadron, 3rd Armored Cavalry Regiment, where he was awarded the Bronze Star.

Show Notes

• Divided We Fall: America's Secession Threat and How to Restore Our Nation
• "I was a First Amendment litigator with a writing hobby."
• Background in the Acapella Churches of Christ: a Restoration Movement from the early-19th century
• "It turned into something kind of separatist, sectarian, and ferociously legalistic."
• "I grew up with a real grounding. grounding and reading the Bible, which actually, ironically enough, was the seed of me leaving the church of Christ."
• "I was a Cold War conservative and a conservative Christian. And they were related, but not, but they weren't inextricably tied together. So for me, my, you know, ideology was downstream of my faith, but I didn't think that my ideology was the inevitable result of my faith."
• Pro-Life Activism
• Representing pro-life individuals
• Existential clash: the confrontation between the Soviet Union and the United States
• Why David French is voting for Kamala Harris in order to save conservative politics
• "My party loyalty has always been related to two things. One is the ideology of the party and the other one is the character of the party. And the party leaders and the people that I vote for, I've always had a character test and an ideological test."
• Bad character and bad policy—"why would I be attached to that? There's no claim on my loyalty there."
• The importance of character
• "If the conservative perspective that I have wants to have any purchase in American politics, MAGA has to lose. Donald Trump has to lose."
• Federalism: a practical understanding that smaller government is better.
• Republican Party increasingly embracing a pro-choice platform
• "If you're going to have a healthy two party system, the distinctions should be around good people of high character approaching policy solutions from different perspectives."
• "One of these parties has sort of left the norms of American. political engagement."
• "I voted for Mitt Romney more than Mitt Romney's probably voted for Mitt Romney."
• "If I'm voting for a politician, I have a test. One is: Do they have the character necessary for the job? And the higher the position they're seeking, the more character that is necessary. And number two: Do they broadly agree with me on the most important policies?"
• "I have very little patience for those people who say I'm somehow not a Christian for voting for a pro-choice candidate. When they're voting for a pro-choice candidate who's been adjudicated a sex abuser, that is difficult for me to discern how that is a more Christian stance."
• Clear, independent thinker
• Logical reasoning and courageous statements
• A living faith by which we think through ideas
• "There's a fine line between stubbornness and courage."
• "In these last 10 years, I've really had to ask myself: Who are you really?"
• David French's parents' example of faith and virtue
• Learning from World War I and World War II history
• "Some of the worst things that have happened in American history have happened because people didn't want to do hard things."
• "I think the sanctification process, though, is difficult. It means that you're being exposed to constantly your own sin is being exposed to yourself."
• Mark asks: "What do you want Christian people, thoughtful, committed, curious, uncertain, tenuous Christian people to, to do between now and the election?"
• 2 Timothy 1:7—"God did not give us a spirit of fear, but of power, of love, and of sound mind."
• Micah 6:8—"What does the Lord require of you, O man? What is good? To act justly, to love kindness, and to walk humbly before the Lord your God."
• Ideological diversity: be curious, seek disagreement
• "If you just show affection for people and curiosity towards their views, anger tends to drain out of a room."
• "College students are full of anxiety about conflict."
• "Fear not."
• The A Team—arming up for battle
• "And they find out that a lot of these folks that they were taught were going to be their enemies are actually just super kind, normal folks."
• "They're equipping them to fight, not to love their neighbor, fight their neighbor, not love their neighbor."
• Mark asks: "What handles would you give people in living in a fear dominated moment in American history?"
• "In receiving anger and fear, do not try to build up a bulletproof thick skin. … Because you know what that does? It often walls you off from legitimate criticism."
• Thick skin, soft heart.
• "An enormous amount of fear is rooted in a sense—a feeling—of non-belonging and loneliness. Isolation and loneliness."
• "People who are more isolated and alone are drawn to these authoritarian movements."
• "Ease the loneliness, build the connection. … Lean into relationship and presence."
• "It was just stunning to me that, against all evidence of scripture, Christians were consigning people to eternal damnation over a vote in a presidential election."
• Miles Law: "Where we stand is based on where we sit."
• Kindness, humility, not living a fear-based angry life
• "If you're in a community where the fruit of the spirit dominate, you can withstand a lot of disagreement."

Production Credits

Conversing is produced and distributed in partnership with Comment Magazine and Fuller Seminary.