Catholic Answers Live #12633 Why Oppose Assisted Suicide? – Why Are You Pro-Choice? - Emily Dinneny
Mar 17, 2026
Emily Dinneny, Catholic convert and online apologist known for Catholic Converts, discusses why legalizing assisted suicide risks vulnerable people. She contrasts palliative care with intentional death. Conversation touches on trauma, lack of healing resources, legislative protection for the unborn, culpability and mercy for providers, and fathers being sidelined in abortion decisions.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Legalizing Suicide Risks Normalizing Killing
- Legalizing physician-assisted suicide normalizes killing as a solution and risks justifying further moral harms beyond individual cases.
- Emily Dinneny argues society should accompany suffering, offering support instead of making killing an accepted public remedy.
Give Pain Relief Even If Life May Shorten
- Provide adequate palliative care and pain management even if it may unintentionally shorten life, because intent matters morally.
- Emily explains tolerating an unintended life-shortening effect differs from intending death, making aggressive pain relief permissible.
Caller Steve's Recovery After Childhood Abuse
- Caller Steve shared childhood abuse and near-attempted suicide, illustrating trauma-driven suicidal thinking.
- He described hospital stays and recovery steps, stressing therapy and programs helped him avoid ending his life.
