Why Theory

Defending Freud (side B)

23 snips
Nov 7, 2019
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Freud Challenged Heteronormative Binaries

  • Freud did not treat homosexuality as a disorder and theorized primary bisexuality as a universal starting point.
  • Hosts cite Freud's letter on homosexuality and his concept of primary bisexuality and polymorphous perversity to show he destabilizes strict heteronormative binaries.
INSIGHT

Sexual Relation Critique Reframes Failure

  • Butler's critique that 'there is no sexual relation' privileges heterosexual failure, but Freud/Lacan treat each sex as its own structural failure.
  • Hosts argue complementarity in some queer narratives (example: neo-noir film with lesbian lovers) can falsely suggest homosexuality escapes that failure.
ADVICE

Read One Major Work Before Dismissing A Thinker

  • Don't dismiss complex theorists wholesale because of one objection; read a major work closely to test its value.
  • Hosts recommend picking a central text (e.g., a major Freud essay) before rejecting the whole corpus to avoid arbitrary dismissal.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app