MLB Opening Day 2026: Overreactions, Waiver Wire Targets & Bold Predictions

Paul Skubal's worst outing ever (5 ER in 0.2 IP), Griffin Jax blows a save, and Jackson Cheerio hits the IL on Opening Day. Joe Bond, AJ Applegarth, and Corey Pieper react live to MLB's Opening Day 2026 chaos, revealing which performances are real and which are noise you should ignore.

The guys break down the biggest Opening Day surprises including O'Neal Cruz's defensive disaster costing Skubal runs, Jeremy Peña sitting despite hitting a homer yesterday, and whether Matt Wallner facing lefties signals everyday playing time. Plus: waiver wire must-adds (Jordan Romano, Ryan Staneck, Jake Bauers), lineup changes that matter (Sal Stewart locked at 1B, Jarren Durán DHing vs lefties), and bold season predictions.

Opening Day overreactions:

• Paul Skubal disaster: 37 pitches, 2 outs, 5 ER (but O'Neal Cruz errors cost him)
• Jackson Cheerio to IL (2-4 weeks, fractured hand from WBC hit-by-pitch)
• Griffin Jax blows save, Garrett Cleavinger gets lit up in TB closer chaos
• Nick Pivetta shelled by Tigers (6 ER in 3 IP) - panic or patience?

Waiver wire targets:

• Jordan Romano (slam dunk add with USA on IL)
• Ryan Staneck (Cardinals closer, got first save)
• Jake Bauers (filling in for Cheerio, went deep today)
• Joey Wiemer (5x5 deep league flyer - former 34 HR/30 SB guy in minors)

Key lineup notes:

• Sal Stewart locked at 1B for Reds (Spencer Steer to LF vs lefties only)
• Jeremy Peña healthy but sat after homer - go trade for him NOW
• Matt Wallner faced lefty, drew 2 walks (35-HR upside if everyday)
• Jarren Durán DHing vs lefties (Joe's bust pick looking wrong already)

Bold predictions:

• AL MVP: Bobby Witt Jr (Corey), Julio Rodriguez (Joe), José Ramírez (AJ)
• NL MVP: Shohei Ohtani (Joe - "literally no way to beat him"), Bryce Harper (AJ)
• AL Cy Young: Garrett Crochet (Corey/Joe), Paul Skubal (AJ - "he'll bounce back")
• NL Cy Young: Chris Sánchez (Corey - "every bit as good as Skubal"), Skubal again (AJ)
• AL Champ: Yankees (Joe), Blue Jays (AJ/Corey)
• World Series: Dodgers over Blue Jays (Corey - "Captain Chalk"), Phillies over Red Sox (AJ)

Plus: Why the Rays lineup around Junior Cameaux is a disaster, Houston's infield puzzle when Peña returns, and Corey's "ride or die" trash league picks already paying off.

Rankings and cheat sheets at fantasysixpack.net/plans (Code: F6PPODS saves 15%)

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.