Called to Communion Dr. Anders and Mormons?
Mar 5, 2026
Discussion of when and how to correct someone using Aquinas-derived criteria. Contrast between imputed faith and formed faith, and how converts can keep good from other traditions. Practical talk on Sunday Mass obligation, applause and rubrics, and etiquette around communion. Reflections on persuasion, religious submission of intellect and will, and spiritual references in Samuel.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
When And How To Admonish A Sinner
- Admonish sinners prudently only when it's a grave matter and the person is likely to listen.
- Dr. David Anders lists three criteria: seriousness, receptivity, and that you are the best-suited person to give the correction.
Faith Alone Versus Formed Faith
- Reformed Protestants see faith as an immediate forensic declaration plus regeneration, while Catholics view justifying faith as faith formed by love.
- Anders contrasts imputed righteousness (Protestant) with intrinsic making-righteous (Catholic) and the necessity of charity.
Don't Be Your Neighbor's Conscience
- If a Catholic friend knowingly skips Sunday Mass, don't take on policing their conscience; it's not your responsibility to force attendance.
- Anders advises informing only if they're ignorant and otherwise leaving admonition to appropriate ministers or charity.