That's So Criminal Finding Nancy Guthrie: Bring in the Psychic - Ep. 18
Mar 10, 2026
A suspicious man was reportedly seen near Nancy’s Tucson home just weeks before she vanished. A renowned psychic sets up outside the property hoping to offer leads. The terrain and hidden escape routes around the neighborhood complicate searches. Family members balance grief with returning to public life while investigators follow tips and a large reward remains active.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Case Lull Doesn’t Mean Closure
- The investigation is in a lull but not cold, with day 38 emphasizing time-consuming casework.
- Lyndon Blake notes many cases reach breakthroughs around the 40-day mark, so quiet may mean progress.
Savannah Guthrie Returns To New York
- Savannah Guthrie briefly returned to New York while keeping hope but showing signs of personal closure.
- Lyndon Blake observed Savannah visited the Today Show set and was seen with her husband and son in New York.
Terrain Creates Many Escape Routes
- Neighborhood layout and terrain create many movement routes and concealment options near Nancy's home.
- Lyndon Blake highlights washes, tunnels, open spaces and lack of grid roads that complicate searches.