
Cosmopod Twilight of World Trotskyism with John Kelly
4 snips
Nov 21, 2022 John Kelly, professor of political history and author of works on Trotskyism. He explores Trotskyist groups as hybrid party-sect formations. Short takes cover doctrine's grip, international splits and why mass parties never formed. Discussion touches on Latin American currents, charismatic leadership, and struggles with gender, sexuality and abuse.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Doctrine Trumps Pragmatism In Trotskyist Politics
- Trotskyist groups prioritize doctrinal correctness over pragmatic policy choices.
- John Kelly shows debates (e.g., Lenin/Trotsky orthodoxy vs. broad-left tactics) are resolved by who best fits canonical doctrine, not by cost/benefit analysis.
Imperialism Debates Break Tiny Trotskyist Groups
- Key doctrinal disputes (e.g., is Argentina imperialist?) decide tactical positions and can split tiny groups.
- Kelly recounts the British Socialist Organizer split over the Falklands where doctrine dictated whether to 'side with Argentina' or call for defeats.
Entryism, Electoral Tactics, And Regional Variations
- Entryism is common in Britain but rare in the US and Argentina; Latin American Trotskyists engage more in electoral politics.
- Kelly links these differences to local party structures and memories of brutal dictatorships that valorize elections.


