
Talking About Organizations Podcast 130: Structure of Scientific Revolutions -- Thomas Kuhn (Part 2)
Oct 28, 2025
They revisit Kuhn’s idea of paradigm shifts and test it against social sciences today. The group debates whether social theories create self-fulfilling effects and whether management studies have a shared core. Conversations cover fragmented academic conversations, cultural anomalies, and whether shocks like the pandemic or AI reshape research priorities.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Aufhebung Explains How Paradigms Reuse Old Elements
- Paradigm syntheses often preserve and transform elements of prior views rather than wholly discarding them.
- Rowan explains Hegel's Aufhebung: synthesis cancels and lifts prior ideas, so methods persist even when theories change.
Old Scientific Ideas Keep Reappearing In New Forms
- Scientific ideas often return in new guises instead of disappearing entirely across revolutions.
- Tom notes examples: occult qualities → Newtonian gravity → Einstein's rejection → quantum entanglement's 'spooky action at a distance'.
Social Paradigms Can Shape The Phenomena They Study
- Social science research changes the phenomena it studies because people adjust to theories about them.
- Tom points to self-fulfilling prophecies: paradigms in social fields can alter behavior, unlike many natural science cases.



