HEATED Debate: Andrew Gold vs Dr Helen Webberly on Mental Illnesses (This is SAD)

Andrew Gold and Dr Helen Webberley clash in one of the most intense and emotionally charged debates we’ve ever hosted on Heretics. In this gripping conversation, Andrew challenges Webberley on one of the most explosive questions in today’s culture war: Is being transgender linked to mental illness? What follows is a heated back-and-forth that exposes the deep divide between clinical interpretation, gender ideology, and the reality of how young people are being treated. If you enjoy sharp, uncompromising arguments that cut through the noise, make sure you subscribe to Heretics Clips: https://www.youtube.com/@hereticsclips/videos

Andrew presses Webberley — the former GenderGP founder who no longer holds a licence to practise medicine in the UK — on why she refuses to acknowledge any mental-health component to gender dysphoria, despite overwhelming public concern and the Cass Review’s findings on safeguarding failures. Andrew questions how children, teens, and vulnerable adults can be properly protected if professionals deny the psychological side entirely. The debate quickly becomes heated as Webberley pushes back, arguing that gender identity should be affirmed without pathologising it, while Andrew warns that refusing to recognise mental-health realities puts patients at risk.

Throughout the conversation, Andrew confronts Webberley with difficult, uncomfortable questions:

• Why won’t she describe gender dysphoria as a mental-health condition?

• Does denying the mental component make proper clinical treatment impossible?

• Why did she face regulatory action and lose her medical licence?

• Is the trans movement encouraging vulnerable people to self-diagnose?

• What responsibility do clinicians have when patients later detransition?

The result is a tense, revealing showdown that showcases two completely different worldviews. Andrew argues that identifying as another gender — or believing one has been “born in the wrong body” — is inseparable from mental distress and should be treated with the same seriousness as any psychological condition. Webberley insists this framing is outdated and harmful. The emotional weight of this disagreement is clear throughout the debate, and the “sad” part, as many viewers will note, is how impossible it seems to reach any common ground.

This is a must-watch for anyone interested in gender medicine, mental health, safeguarding, or the contentious battles shaping modern identity politics.

🔥 Watch the full podcast here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Lh8SVtqpQI

#AndrewGold #HelenWebberley #GenderDebate #TransIssues #MentalHealth #GenderDysphoria #CultureWar #Heretics #HereticsClips #Debate

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices