
Know Your Enemy The Long Farewell to Majority Rule? (w/ Joshua Tait)
May 18, 2021
Historian Joshua Tait discusses the American Right's roots in anti-democratic thought, from John C. Calhoun to 1950s conservatives. They explore Calhoun's influence on modern conservatism, views on majority rule, and a conservative writer's unique style.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Calhoun As Filibuster Origin
- John C. Calhoun originated the filibuster as a counter-majoritarian tool to protect Southern slavepower.
- That tactic later became the Senate mechanism used for decades to block civil-rights legislation.
Kirk's Mythic Calhoun
- Russell Kirk lifted Calhoun out of his historical context and presented him as a principled opponent of mass democracy.
- Kirk's mythic portrait made Calhoun influential in midcentury conservative thought despite slavery's role in his politics.
Concurrent Majorities Explained
- Calhoun's idea of concurrent majorities argued numerical majorities miss important regional and interest differences.
- That logic influenced thinkers who wanted deliberative checks beyond simple head-count voting.

