The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL The Table: Cutting 10 Super Bowl contenders down to eight
28 snips
Nov 20, 2025 The hosts dive into their Lombardi Table concept, discussing which NFL teams are genuine Super Bowl contenders. They agree on a core group of four teams like the Eagles and Rams while debating the exclusion of others, including the Buccaneers and Colts. A spirited discussion highlights the Ravens' strong defense and the Lions' impressive performance. The Chiefs' playoff prospects spark intriguing debates. Ultimately, the final eight contenders are revealed, setting the stage for a thrilling remainder of the season.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Cut Based On Structure, Not Hype
- Eliminate teams with clear structural flaws rather than hoping for late-season fixes.
- Use roster depth, injuries, and organizational track record to guide which contenders to cut.
Judge Teams Holistically
- Don't let a strong individual season blind you to roster-wide weaknesses.
- Evaluate offensive line, defense, and depth before labeling a team a genuine Super Bowl threat.
MVP Play ≠ Championship Ceiling
- Drake Maye's MVP-style production doesn't automatically make the Patriots Super Bowl contenders.
- The hosts distinguish MVP-level quarterback play from roster quality needed to win multiple playoff games.