Two Likely Outcomes: Moderation or Uprising

A Note from James:

What is actually going on in Iran?

I have Brandon Webb on the show today. He’s a former Navy SEAL, he’s written a ton of books about the military and life in the military, then he wrote a murder mystery series set in the military, and now he has a parenting book out.

Brandon also runs SOFREP.com, a major military intelligence news site. He came on for a quick episode to answer the big question: what is actually happening in Iran, and what might happen next?

Episode Description:

In this fast-moving topical episode, James talks with former Navy SEAL and SOFREP founder Brandon Webb about Iran, regime instability, the Strait of Hormuz, and how modern military power is being used differently than it was in Iraq and Afghanistan.

Brandon argues that the top levels of Iran’s leadership have been badly disrupted, creating confusion about who is actually in charge and who the U.S. or Israel could negotiate with. From his perspective, that leadership vacuum creates two possible outcomes: either a moderate power center emerges inside the regime, or Iran’s already strained economy worsens and the population rises up again.

The conversation also tackles the biggest fear many listeners may have: whether this turns into another long, grinding U.S. nation-building project. Brandon’s answer is no. He sees this as a different kind of military and intelligence operation—less about occupying territory, more about using special operations, air dominance, intelligence networks, and local opposition pressure.

What makes this episode useful is that it cuts through the broad panic and gives listeners a clear framework: leadership disruption, economic pressure, domestic unrest, proxy networks, energy markets, and the question of whether Iran’s regime can still hold itself together.

What You’ll Learn:

• Why Brandon thinks Iran’s leadership disruption is the key fact driving everything else.
• The two outcomes he sees as most likely: a moderate negotiator emerging or a popular uprising.
• Why he does not think this becomes Iraq-style nation-building.
• How Iran’s proxy network shapes the conflict beyond Iran’s borders.
• Why the Strait of Hormuz threat may matter less than it would have decades ago.
• How Brandon thinks special operations and intelligence support may define the next phase of modern warfare.

Timestamped Chapters:

• [02:00] A Note from James: what is actually happening in Iran?
• [02:33] Brandon’s two most likely outcomes
• [02:35] Leadership disruption inside Iran
• [03:28] The Strait of Hormuz as Iran’s “ace” card
• [04:00] Why the nuclear issue matters
• [04:51] Economic pressure and oil sales
• [05:08] Why civilians may be hesitant to rise up again
• [05:32] Moderate regime figure or popular uprising?
• [06:00] Why Brandon sees Iran as a long-standing threat
• [06:23] Iran’s proxies in Yemen, Lebanon, and Gaza
• [06:51] Who is actually in charge inside Iran?
• [07:41] What a leadership vacuum might look like
• [08:19] CIA, Mossad, and opposition support
• [09:55] Is this another Iraq?
• [10:14] Brandon’s view of modern military force
• [10:45] Venezuela as a case study
• [11:48] Regime change vs. nation-building
• [12:20] Strait of Hormuz, oil prices, and infrastructure risk
• [12:41] Why Brandon thinks oil disruption may be manageable
• [13:30] Alternative oil flows and pressure on China
• [14:02] James summarizes Brandon’s view
• [14:36] Why Brandon thinks this is not a boots-on-the-ground war
• [15:26] What Afghanistan should have taught the U.S.
• [16:00] Dubai, UAE, and regional risk
• [16:36] Why Iran may have targeted the UAE
• [17:12] Closing thoughts

Additional Resources:

• SOFREP, the military and foreign policy news site Brandon Webb runs as editor-in-chief.
• Brandon Webb’s official website and biography.
• Brandon Webb’s books page.
• Puddle Jumpers, Brandon Webb’s new parenting book.
• Wall Street Journal interview with Brandon Webb about Puddle Jumpers.

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.