Are Current Market Returns Sustainable?

The S&P 500 just notched its third consecutive year of double-digit gains, pushing valuations near a 25-year high — yet market veteran Brian Feroldi isn't hitting the panic button. In this deep-dive, Brad sits down with Brian to dissect where the market stands heading into the end of 2025, why sustained growth at this pace defies historical precedent, and how Brian is personally navigating the tension between staying invested and managing risk. The conversation shifts to the practical — how AI can supercharge stock analysis when fed the right prompts, why dollar-cost averaging remains unshakable for most investors, and whether bonds still have a place in modern portfolios. Brian also fields listener questions on individual stock picks, fee-only financial advisors, and the mental game of investing during uncertain times.

Key Topics & Timestamps

Introduction to the State of the Stock Market (00:01:01)
S&P 500 has delivered over 15% growth year-to-date, marking three consecutive years of double-digit returns.

Current Market Valuation Insights (00:02:04)
Historical performance indicators signal high valuation levels. "Sustained double-digit growth in the stock market isn't feasible long-term." (00:02:15)

Brian Feroldi's Personal Investment Strategy (00:05:00)
Brian maintains a 30% cash position during high valuations while keeping 70% invested. "Investment strategies should reflect personal financial situations." (00:05:00)

Impact of AI on Stock Analysis (00:24:19)
AI can dramatically enhance stock analysis when given clear directives. "As long as you're giving AI clear directions, it can provide incredible analysis." (00:26:10)

Audience Questions and Answers (00:30:00)
Discussion on individual stocks vs. index funds and tax implications.

Benefits of Fee-Only Financial Advisors (00:53:24)
Fee-only hourly consultations offer transparent financial advice versus traditional AUM models.

Conclusions and Future Predictions (01:03:05)
Summary of thoughts on market sustainability and investor strategies moving forward.

Resources

• Notebook LLM (00:25:05)
• Finviz Stock Screener (00:40:09)
• Nectarine (00:53:24)
• OpenPath Financial (00:54:32)
• Abundo Wealth (00:54:32)

Key Quotes

Brian Feroldi: "Sustained double-digit growth in the stock market isn't feasible long-term." (00:02:15)

Brian Feroldi: "Investment strategies should reflect personal financial situations." (00:05:00)

Brian Feroldi: "Dollar-cost averaging into total stock market index funds is just so rock solid." (00:21:27)

Brian Feroldi: "As long as you're giving AI clear directions, it can provide incredible analysis." (00:26:10)

▶ Listen Next: Ep. 572 — Bias Towards Action: The Adventure List(s) | Essential Listening

Support the Show
We work hard to keep ChooseFI ad-free for a clean listening experience. The easiest way to support us is to use our Top Recommended Cards page when signing up for your next travel rewards credit card.